Texas’ love affair with renewable energy is undeniable. But even after another banner year for clean energy in the state, a market redesign, fueled by political rhetoric from state leaders, could thwart future deployment, experts say.
Wind and solar accounted for nearly all new generating capacity added to the Texas grid in 2021, according to newly-released market data. S&P Global Market Intelligence notes that power plant operators added 8,139 megawatts of new generating capacity to the ERCOT market last year — 42% came from wind and 40% from solar. Natural gas-fired additions made up 13% of the new capacity.
Nationally, wind and solar made up a slightly smaller share of new generating capacity — 41% and 36%, respectively — of the 27,959 MW of capacity added.
Jeff Clark, president and CEO of the Texas-based Advanced Power Alliance, said Texas continues to benefit from corporate and consumer demand for clean electricity and long-term price certainty. He added that broad electrification, including within the transportation sector, offers opportunities for even more growth.
“These are tremendously exciting times in the clean power sector, thanks to continued improvements in technology and economics,” said Clark, who also advocates for the replacement of coal-fired generating capacity with cleaner natural gas. “The addition of energy storage projects, and the extraordinarily large pipeline of projects ahead, will bring greater reliable and resilient integration of renewables, accelerating these trends.”
Broad Reach Power announced this week that its North Fork and Bat Cave battery storage projects in Central Texas have been placed into service with ERCOT, each bringing online 100 MW/100 MWh. Broad Reach Power now has 300 MW of dispatchable storage resources in ERCOT. (Source: Broad Reach Power)
California leads new energy storage capacity additions. But Texas is close behind
ERCOT is gaining ground in the energy storage space. While California claimed the largest battery energy storage system in 2021 — the 230 MW McCoy Battery Storage Project — Texas added the next two largest systems with the 102 MW Gambit Battery Energy Storage Park and 100 MW North Fork Battery Storage Project.
Paired with the rapid deployment of renewables, energy storage can provide resilient, clean electricity to residential, commercial, and industrial customers in Texas, where an extreme winter storm nearly caused a complete collapse of the electric grid in Feb. 2021. The California ISO region grabbed 55% of new energy storage capacity in 2021, while Texas took 38%.
Dr. Joshua Rhodes, a research associate at the University of Texas at Austin, and a founding partner of energy consultancy IdeaSmiths, said additional incentives for energy storage and investments in transmission infrastructure would unlock even greater deployment of renewable energy resources in Texas.
“The interconnection queue (at ERCOT) is full. It’s comically full,” Rhodes told Renewable Energy World. “I think we’re going to see a lot more storage connected to the grid.
“Before, the only way we could get more renewables on the system is to build more transmission. That’s not really true anymore with storage.”
Pattern Energy’s Gulf Wind facility in Kenedy County, Texas
Can Texas keep up the renewables momentum?
Uncertainty surrounding a market redesign by the Texas Public Utilities Commission has started to slow the deployment of renewable energy resources, experts say.
In July, Abbott directed the PUC to “allocate reliability costs to generation resources that cannot guarantee their own availability, such as wind or solar power” and to “streamline incentives within the ERCOT market to foster the development and maintenance of adequate and reliable sources of power, like natural gas, coal, and nuclear power.”
Doug Lewin, a Texas-based energy consultant, said adding ancillary service costs to renewables would be a “major change” that could threaten future deployment in the state.
“It will really stifle development,” Lewin said. “There’s not a lot of interest in building new thermal plants. It could leave Texas really in a terrible spot where we’ve disadvantaged renewables enough that we’re not getting them, and the market just isn’t good enough for thermals to get in.
“There’s a real danger there.”